Heterogeneity, Yield Distributions, and Climate Change: Implications for Solvency of Crop Insurance Programs

Published in American Journal of Agricultural Economics (2025), 2024

Best Paper Award from the Applied Risk Analysis Section of the AAEA (2025)

Climate change continues to fuel concern about the future cost of publicly-subsidized crop insurance programs in developed nations. These climate changes are expected to alter the upper and lower tails of crop yield distributions differently. This may best be captured by modeling the climate-yield relationship heterogeneously across different parts of the yield distribution. To this end, we consider a mixture model with the component probabilities expressed as nonparametric functions (to capture non-linearities) of weather variables estimated by machine learning methods (neural net). By doing so, we are able to identify possibly heterogeneous effects of climate change on each component, the mixing probabilities, and thus all moments of the yield distribution. We find changing climate alters, quite significantly, the entire shape of the yield distribution. The overall mass of the lower tail tends to increase as temperatures rise, to the point where some yield distributions even become positively skewed. Under the most probable climate scenario (RCP 4.5), the effect of climate on expected losses is small; positive in the short term and negative in the long-term. Importantly, we find differing rates of technological change to consistently raise insurance costs with quicker rates of temperature, relative to the rate of technological change, ameliorating this effect. Overall, the resulting insurance costs from climate are considerably less drastic than previous work due to heterogeneous effects across the yield distribution raising the probability of lower component yields and slowing the rate of technology